Aired: 1993 ABC, 1994 FOX
Questionable Dad: Jay Sherman (voice of Jon Lovitz) / Divorced 
Why It Doesn’t Count: Jay Sherman doesn’t have primary custody. His ex-wife Ardith does. However, he does have his son Marty with him on many occasions. Under the Martin Tupper Sub-Rule of Parental Possession, Jay’s not custodial, and ineligible. Sorry!